Why do we eat what we eat?
A lesson plan to go with “Why is eating healthy so hard?” from the March-April 2010 issue of L.A. Youth. In this article, Ernesto writes about the challenges he faces trying to eat better.
By Amanda Riddle, co-managing editor
Subjects: language arts, health, social studies, life skills
Suggested Time Allowance: 45 minutes-1 hour
• copies of the L.A. Youth article “Why is eating healthy so hard?” (one per student)
• pens and paper
• white board or blackboard
Students will examine what factors influence what they eat.
In Los Angeles County, there are more than four times as many fast food restaurants and convenience stores as supermarkets and produce vendors, according to the California Center for Public Health Advocacy. The Center also found that people who live near an abundance of fast food and convenience stores have significantly higher rates of obesity and diabetes. We all know we’re supposed to watch what we eat, but where we live influences how easy that is. It’s even harder for teens who don’t have control over the food their parents buy or what’s offered at school. In a Healthy Kids survey, only half of ninth and 11th graders said they had had five or more fruits and vegetables in the past 24 hours. But two-thirds of respondents said they’d eaten french fries, potato chips or other fried potatoes in the past day.
Ask each student what they ate yesterday and have them write down their answers. Next to each item, ask them to explain why they selected that food. Was it the only thing to eat in the house? What the school was serving or their parents cooked for dinner? They were busy or short on cash and had to grab fast food? Or just that was what they wanted?
Next, ask your students how they feel about their food choices? Do they wish they ate healthier? What makes it hard? Their answers may be both factors they can’t control, such as the food available in their community, school and at home, and what they can control, like what snacks they choose to eat and how much they eat.
Have your students read Ernesto’s story “Why is eating healthy so hard?” on page 16. After reading the story, as a discussion measuring their reading comprehension, ask students to answer the following questions about the story:
What reasons does Ernesto give for not eating healthy?
• He’s always eaten junk food.
• His mom brings home fast food or cooks the fattening meals his dad wants.
• He doesn’t know how to cook.
• There are a lot of fast food restaurants and convenience stores where he lives.
• The produce where he lives isn’t fresh.
What changes did Ernesto make to try to lose weight?
• He started exercising.
• He switched to eating the school’s vegetarian lunch option.
• He is trying to eat more fruit.
• He distracts himself with work, reading or video games so he won’t eat when he’s bored and not hungry.
As Ernesto made these changes, what prevented him from being as healthy as he wants?
• He doesn’t have control over the food in his home or neighborhood.
• He doesn’t know how to cook.
• His mom can’t take him to the gym anymore.
• He sometimes gives in.
What did he learn are ways to overcome those obstacles?
• Pick a healthier snack when he’s at a convenience store.
• Read food labels and avoid foods that have trans fats and MSG.
• Don’t give up.
After reading the story, ask your students what they think of Ernesto’s efforts to eat healthier. What did they think about the things he couldn’t control? Could they relate to his frustrations? Did his observations about what prevented him from eating healthier make them think about what was influencing what they ate? Do they think it’s important to think critically about the reasons why they eat what they do? Do they expect their parents, schools and neighborhood markets to make it easier to eat right? They may not be able to change everything about their environment but being aware of the factors that influence what they eat can help them make better choices.
Have students write an essay about how the factors that they can’t control make it hard to eat right. Then have them write about one thing they’d like changed. They may want a store in their neighborhood to offer fresher produce. Or their school to provide healthier meals at lunch or more time to eat. Or at home they wish there were healthier snacks.
They may not be able to change factors beyond their control but they can still try to make better choices. Challenge your students to follow some of Ernesto’s advice about eating healthier. They can try for a few days or even a week. Have them report back what they thought of the changes they made. Do they think they can stick with it?